🔥 Trending
The Drives Marquee Franchise NFC Shame Brady Killer Only HOF Teammate Tiki "Comical" Daniel Jones Eli vs. Namath Eli vs. Warner Toughest Game Ever TO Crying MVP Club Arguments Destroyed Video Evidence The Verdict
The Case for Canton

Eli Manning is a Hall of Famer.

Two rings. Two MVPs. Two dynasties destroyed. This is the definitive argument.

2
SB Rings
2
SB MVPs
57,023
Yards
366
TDs
42
GW Drives
210
Starts

📋 All Articles

14 pieces of evidence
Must Read
The Drives That Changed History
Play-by-play breakdown of both Super Bowl game-winning drives. The Helmet Catch. The Manningham Throw. Every snap that killed a dynasty.
Playoffs→
XLII
XLVI
2× Super Bowl MVP
Hot Take
The NFC Was Wide Open. They Had No Excuse.
Brees, Rodgers, Newton, Wilson, Ryan, Stafford — they all had more help than Eli. They all won less. Every weapon named.
Vs. Others→
Iconic
The Toughest Single Performance in NFL History
2011 NFC Championship at Candlestick. 6 sacks. 58 attempts. Got up every time. Won in OT.
Playoffs→
Rivalry
The Brady Killer
2–0 in Super Bowls. Two fourth-quarter game-winning drives. Brady lost three — Eli was responsible for two.
Vs. Others→
The Case
The Résumé
11th all-time in yards and TDs. More touchdowns than Elway, Moon, and Montana. Zero HOF offensive teammates.
Stats→
Exclusive
The Multiple Super Bowl MVP Club
Six members in NFL history. Five are in the Hall or not yet eligible. Eli is the only exception.
The Case→
Moment
Eli Sent TO Home Crying
2007 Divisional Round at Dallas. TO talked trash all week. After the game, Terrell Owens sobbed at the podium.
Playoffs→
Analysis
Every Argument Against Him. Destroyed.
.500 QB? Interceptions? Only four Pro Bowls? Joe Flacco is a Pro Bowler. Shedeur Sanders is a Pro Bowler. Come on.
The Case→
Legendary
The Road Warrior
Two legendary playoff runs. Beat the #1 seed in Dallas. Won in -23°F at Lambeau. Destroyed 15-1 Green Bay.
Playoffs→
Evidence
He Made Everyone Better — Then They Vanished
Tyree, Manningham, Nicks, Boss, Ballard, Shockey, Cruz, OBJ — every single one vanished after leaving Eli's huddle.
The Case→
Data
The Precedents: If They're In, Eli's In
Eli vs. Warner. Eli vs. Namath. Every multi-SB winner. Stafford is Canton-bound with one ring — what about two?
Stats→
History
The 2004 Draft Class
Eli vs. Rivers vs. Big Ben. Two rings, two MVPs, zero off-field scandals. Eli won the draft.
Vs. Others→
Watch
Video Evidence
12 official links. The Helmet Catch. The Manningham Throw. Career highlights. Watch every play.
Video→
Hot Take
Tiki Barber Called Him "Comical." Eli Won Two Super Bowls.
Tiki retired and trashed Eli on national TV. The next season, Eli beat the 18-0 Patriots. Tiki ended up in the Fan Controlled Football league.
Vs. Others→
Legacy
Daniel Jones Proved How Good Eli Was
$160M contract. 24-44-1 record. 47 fumbles. The franchise collapsed the moment Eli left. That's not coincidence — that's proof.
Vs. Others→
Precedent
Eli vs. Kurt Warner: The Case Is Overwhelming
Warner is a Hall of Famer Hall of Famer with 1 ring and 1 SB MVP. Eli has two of each — plus 25,000 more career yards.
Vs. Others→
Precedent
Eli vs. Joe Namath: Broadway Joe Had More INTs Than TDs
Namath threw more interceptions than touchdowns and is in the Hall. Eli beats him in literally every category. Explain that.
Vs. Others→
The Case
The Only Hall of Famer He Played With Was a Defensive End
Michael Strahan. That's it. Brady had Gronk and Moss. Peyton had Harrison and James. Montana had Rice. Eli had nobody.
Stats→
Must Read
The Face of the NFL's Marquee Franchise. Two Titles. Not in the Hall. Ludicrous.
16 years as the New York Giants' QB. Biggest media market. Two championships. Every other franchise QB with 2+ rings is in Canton. Eli is the exception.
The Case→
Final Word
The Verdict: Give Him the Gold Jacket
There is no argument left. There is no counter that holds up. Put him in Canton.
Verdict→